Too Faced

Butter Pecan in other brands

Born This Way Matte 24 Hour Foundation · Liquid and cream

Depth: Lighter than 11% of the shades in our data
Undertone: Listed as warm from its retail listing
Swatch: Reads in between warm and cool #9e4d1e
Data: Retailer swatch, January 2021 (how we collect it)

The closest shade in another brand is Lancôme 540 Suede in Dual Finish Multi-Tasking Lightweight Pressed Powder Foundation (likely close). In all, 35 ranges have a likely-close shade and 81 brands have one worth trying.

Closest shade in each brand

The 40 closest of 81 brands. The other 41 brands are listed below.

One shade per brand, closest first. Labels: Likely close under 4.5, Worth sampling 4.5 to 10. What these mean.

Lancôme

540 Suede · Dual Finish Multi-Tasking Lightweight Pressed Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
L'Oréal

515 - Copper · Infallible 32 Hour Lightweight Fresh Wear Longwear Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Ulta Beauty

Tan Neutral · Youthful Glow Foundation Serum Drops

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Pacifica

04CD Cool Deep · Alight Clean Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Juvia's Place

230 Malawi · I Am Magic Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Revlon

500 Walnut · ColorStay Makeup For Normal/Dry Skin

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Wet n Wild

Espresso · PhotoFocus Liquid Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
ZOEVA

350W Masterful · Authentik Skin Natural Luminous Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
It Cosmetics

Rich Honey · Bye Bye Foundation Full Coverage Moisturizer with SPF 50+

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Smashbox

4.25 · Studio Skin 24 Hour Oil-Free Hydra Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
KVD Vegan Beauty

67 Deep C · Lock-It Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
bareMinerals

23 Medium Dark · Matte Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 15

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-cool
Benefit Cosmetics

Shade 10 Deep Warm · Hello Happy Flawless Brightening Foundation SPF 15

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Marc Jacobs Beauty

84 Cocoa Medium · Re(marc)able Full Cover Foundation Concentrate

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Smith & Cult

450 Cool · Veiled Threat Weightless Micro-Blurring Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads lighter · listed cool
Almay

900 Cappuccino · Clear Complexion Make Myself Clear Makeup

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
e.l.f. Cosmetics

51 Deep Cool · Soft Glam Satin Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Fenty Beauty

440 · Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Longwear Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Natasha Denona

P10 - Deep Peach · Hy-Glam Serum Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
MAC

NW47 · Studio Fix Soft Matte Foundation Stick

Likely close Swatch reads lighter · listed neutral
Haus Labs

470 Medium Deep · Triclone Skin Tech Medium Coverage Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Kosas

Medium Deep Neutral Warm 340 · Revealer Skin-Improving Foundation SPF 25

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Bobbi Brown

Walnut · Skin Long-Wear Weightless Foundation SPF 15

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Catrice

080 Neutral Pecan · True Skin Hydrating Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Charlotte Tilbury

14 COOL · Airbrush Flawless Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Pat McGrath Labs

31 Deep · Sublime Perfection Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Makeup Revolution

F13 · Conceal & Hydrate Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Maybelline

368 Deep Golden · Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Physicians Formula

DpC1 · The Healthy Foundation SPF 20

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer
Rare Beauty

460W · Liquid Touch Weightless Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads lighter · listed warm
NARS

D4 Namibia · Sheer Glow Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Perricone MD

Rich · No Makeup Foundation Serum Broad Spectrum SPF 20

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer
Too Faced

Chai · Born This Way Undetectable Medium-to-Full Coverage Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads deeper · listed warm
Clinique

WN 124 Sienna · Even Better Glow Light Reflecting Makeup Broad Spectrum SPF 15

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer · listed neutral-warm
Becca Cosmetics

5W2 Maple · Ultimate Coverage 24 Hour Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Exa

170 Paetynn · High Fidelity Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
PÜR

DP6 Deep · 4-in-1 Pressed Mineral Powder Foundation SPF 15

Worth sampling Swatch reads cooler · listed cool
Dose Of Colors

130 Dark · Meet Your Hue Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Milani

Chestnut · Conceal + Perfect 2-in-1 Foundation + Concealer

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same
UOMA Beauty

T1C Black Pearl · Say What?! Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed cool

Closest shade in the other 41 brands

A to Z by brand. The 40 above are closer; open a shade to see how close it is.

Filter every range in the shade finder

Next to it in Born This Way Matte 24 Hour Foundation

Mocha (lighter)
Maple (deeper)

Colours come from retailer swatch photos taken in January 2021. Test a shade on your jaw in daylight before you buy.